The Pie Hole

Discover The Pie Hole Pizza Takeaway at 320 Mayville Rd, Bethel, ME. Enjoy delicious paninis, hearty sandwiches, meatball subs, flavorful toppings, and freshly baked cookies. Friendly staff and quality ingredients await!

Welcome to The Pie Hole

Signature Dining Experience

The Pie Hole
The Pie Hole
The Pie Hole
The Pie Hole

Discover a slice of heaven at The Pie Hole Pizza Takeaway in Bethel, Maine. This local eatery specializes in crafting mouthwatering pizzas, hearty subs, and delicious paninis that satisfy every craving. With a menu designed for comfort food lovers, The Pie Hole offers a delightful variety of specialty pies, including the crowd-pleasing Supreme Pie and the flavorful Meat Lovah. The inviting atmosphere lures guests in, making it a perfect stop for families, friends, or anyone in need of a quick bite. No matter the order, you’ll find that the friendly staff enhances your experience with every visit. Located at 320 Mayville Rd, The Pie Hole stands out not just for its food, but also for its friendly service and community spirit.

Location & Contact

Address

320 Mayville Rd, Bethel, ME 04217, United States

Phone

+1 207-824-2050

Social Media

About

The Pie Hole
The Pie Hole
The Pie Hole
The Pie Hole

The Pie Hole stands as a testament to the vibrant food culture in Bethel, ME, where locals prioritize quality ingredients and friendly service. This eatery opened its doors to the community with a mission to deliver delicious comfort food that brings people together. With a robust menu featuring 20 items, there’s something to please every palate. From the traditional pepperoni pizza to the unique Luau pie topped with pineapple, the offerings showcase creativity blended with classic flavors.

The menu also includes a selection of paninis, which are perfect for those looking for a quick, savory meal on the go. Signature sandwiches like the Spicy Italian Panini and Reuben have won over many hungry customers. For subs, The Pie Hole never disappoints. Each sub features fresh ingredients packed into soft, fresh bread, ensuring every bite is juicy and flavorful. The average price of $11.05 for subs reflects the generous portions and quality of the ingredients.

Not only does The Pie Hole focus on tasty food, but it prides itself on maintaining a welcoming environment. Polite staff members greet customers with a smile, making dining here an enjoyable experience. The eatery has developed a loyal customer base, where word of mouth carries its reputation as a go-to destination for satisfying meals. By choosing to source local ingredients whenever possible, The Pie Hole not only supports the community but also contributes to the authenticity of its flavors. This commitment to quality is evident in every dish served, whether it’s the carefully crafted sauces or the perfectly baked crust that leaves you craving more.

In a town like Bethel, known for its outdoor activities and stunning landscapes, The Pie Hole provides an ideal post-adventure dining spot. Whether you’re coming back from a hike or a day on the slopes, this local gem welcomes all with delicious food and a warm atmosphere that feels like home.

Work Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday3-8 PM
  • Saturday3-7 PM

The Pie Hole combines diverse culinary choices with a friendly ambiance, making it a beloved spot in Bethel. Offering a selection of pizzas ranging from the 12" Small to the 16" Large, there’s something for everyone. The gluten-free 10" Cauliflower Crust ensures inclusivity for those with dietary restrictions. In addition to pizzas, The Pie Hole serves an array of subs. Options like the Italian and Meatball subs pack flavor and freshness into every bite, making them popular among locals. Don’t overlook the paninis—each grilled to perfection with fillings that comfort the soul.

Rounding off the menu, the tempting chocolate chip cookies offer the perfect sweet finale. With an average price of $11.28, you get great value for generously portioned meals that satisfy.

The Pie Hole

The exterior of The Pie Hole captivates passersby with its charming mountain-cottage design, complete with inviting signs that hint at the delights within. Nestled comfortably along Mayville Rd, it features a cozy patio space for outdoor dining, perfect for enjoying sunny days in Bethel. The welcoming vibe draws in locals and visitors alike. Inside, the décor maintains a casual, relaxed atmosphere, ensuring every patron feels at home. Whether you're grabbing takeout or enjoying a meal in, the inviting setting enhances the experience.

With laughter and conversations filling the air, it’s a place where friendships blossom over hearty meals. The love for community shines here, making each visit a little more special.

Customer Reviews

I will say at first I was a bit put off by the voicemail message when I called. It made me wonder "did they take the phone off the hook? Do they not want to take phone orders?" I realized after a few tries, they were just on the other line. Nonetheless, it was a bit discouraging. Now on to the important part..... This pizza can be described in one word....AMAZING!! I will however use more words. :) I like my pizza well done, I ordered it like that and they NAILED IT! The cheese, the sauce and most important to me THE CRUST were fantastic! Customer service was friendly, and efficient. Gentleman working the counter was polite and the lady who gave me the pizza was just the same. All in all, it was a great experience! I'll come back over and over for food and service like this! Thank you!

E
Eric

Lots of ample parking that is handicap friendly (the door is too). The building felt pretty chilly and was dimly lit but it wasn't dirty. The bathroom was gender neutral, family, nursing, and handicapped friendly. Nice, big bathroom that is clean but also dimly lit. Could also have been super error. When I walked in I noticed they had a few video game machines and a cooler with a few drinks. My order was ready and it was nicely put together. The menu is small but they have perfected it and are good at what they do :) Paninis, pizza, couple hot subs and a couple italian sun options. No complaints :)

J
Jade W.

BEST Steak Bomb anywhere near Bethel hands down. Do yourself a favor and order an extra just for leftovers or that husband that likes to eat your food.

S
SocialManas A.

Great food and service. We got sandwiches and they were excellent. The sandwiches were loaded with toppings.

E
Esther P.

Quiet night. Girl up front was polite. Man out back was helpful. Pizza was great.

J
Justin S.

Friendly staff, good food, outdoor seating.

B
Brian L.